Skip to main content
Draftly for employers
Employer document

Demand for explanation in South Africa.

Something has been reported about an employee and you do not yet know whether it calls for discipline. Before deciding, you can ask them to put their side in writing. This page explains what that request is for, the wording that keeps it a request rather than an accusation, and the fields Draftly's form needs from you.

A question, not a charge

Asked before you decide.

A demand for explanation, also called a show cause or give reasons letter, asks the employee to account for an incident or a pattern of conduct within a set time. It comes at the start, when the employer has a report or an observation and has not yet chosen whether to start a disciplinary process at all.

That timing is what defines it. The letter does not allege that a rule was broken, does not record a warning and does not announce a hearing. An explanation that clears the matter up can end it there. One that does not, or no reply at all, leaves you to decide the next step on what you then know.

Employers reach for it when the facts are unclear: a shortage on a till count, a vehicle returned with damage, an unexplained gap in a shift. Hearing the employee's version early can save a hearing that was never needed, and it helps you frame accurate allegations if one is.

How it fits the law

It does not stand in for a hearing.

Under section 188(1) of the Labour Relations Act, a dismissal that is not automatically unfair is still unfair if the employer cannot prove both a fair reason and a fair procedure. Item 11 of the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, gazetted in September 2025, describes that procedure. Before a decision to dismiss, the employee should usually be told of the allegations, given reasonable time to prepare and respond to them and to the proposed sanction, and allowed the help of a fellow employee or a union representative.

A written explanation given at the outset is a different thing. It is asked for before any charge has been framed and with no sanction proposed. This page does not treat that reply as the opportunity to respond that item 11 describes. If the matter goes further, give notice of the allegations and a chance to answer them. Item 11 also says that enquiry need not be formal, so what follows can suit the size of your business.

What goes in it

Five parts and an acknowledgement.

Draftly's drafting instructions set the letter out in this order:

  • The details: the date of the incident, the response deadline, and the manager who is asking.
  • The matter itself, described as something reported or observed, with its date and place where known.
  • The questions the employee must answer, numbered. If you supply none, the letter asks them to explain the circumstances and give any reasons or context they think relevant.
  • What is expected of them: a written account by the deadline, framed as their chance to be heard before you decide whether to go any further.
  • Notes that no decision has been taken, that their reply will be genuinely considered, and that if nothing arrives in time a decision may be made on the information already available.

The instructions also call for an acknowledgement of receipt for the employee to sign and date, and a separate line for a witness to sign if the employee refuses.

The wording

Reported, alleged, requested.

The quickest way to spoil this letter is to write it as if the answer were already known. “You damaged the vehicle and failed to report it” is a finding. “It has been reported that the vehicle in your care was damaged and that the damage was not reported” is a matter to be explained. An employee who receives the first version has good reason to think their reply will change nothing.

Draftly's drafting instructions for this type are strict about it. They tell Draftly never to use the “in that” structure a formal charge sheet uses, never to suggest guilt and never to threaten a particular penalty, to carry the letter with phrases such as “alleged”, “it is reported that” and “you are requested to explain”, and to say in terms that nothing has been decided. Put the matter on the form in the same register, because whatever you type there shapes the paragraph the employee reads first.

The deadline

Long enough to answer properly.

The response deadline is a free-text field that opens at 48 hours. That figure is Draftly's starting value, not a period set by the Act or the Code, and this page states no legal minimum. Change it to suit the matter: a question about a single shift may need less thought than one about months of stock records, and an employee on leave or on a night roster needs a date they can actually meet.

If you set something shorter, Draftly's drafting instructions tell it to raise a flag. Flags sit on the review panel. It is printed as the last page of the same Word and PDF file, headed as not for distribution to the employee, so read the flags and then take that page out before the letter is handed over.

Drafting it with Draftly

The fields you must fill.

Pick the employee from your directory or type them in by name, employee number and position, and then complete three case fields:

  • The matter requiring explanation: what was reported or seen, in neutral words.
  • Response deadline: when the written account is due.
  • Issuing manager name: who is asking for the explanation and will sign.

Everything else is optional. The incident date gives the employee a fixed point to respond to. The questions field takes one question per line; leave it empty and the letter makes a general request instead. The manager's role is optional too. This form will only generate once your account has a disciplinary code loaded.

This letter is not a warning. It carries no validity period and leaves the employee's existing warnings untouched. If the explanation does not resolve the matter and you decide to proceed, the next document is usually a notice of hearing, and the disciplinary hearing guide covers what the Code expects at that stage.

For employers

Draft the demand for explanation from your facts.

Draftly drafts the demand for explanation from the facts you enter and your own disciplinary code. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.

What this page will not do

It covers the written request for an employee's account made before any charge. It does not say whether you must send one, how long the employee must be given, or how a reply or a silence should weigh at a later hearing.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.