Skip to main content
Draftly for employers
Employer document

Performance reviews in South Africa.

A performance review looks back over a defined review period and records how the employee did against the objectives set for it. It names what went well, what could grow, and what the next period should aim for. It is part of running a team, and it should read that way.

Where it sits

Routine management, not a process.

A review exists for the employee as much as for the employer: a written account of the period that both sides can come back to. Draftly builds it on that footing. Its instructions describe the document as a management and development record, and say plainly that it is not a disciplinary document, not a warning and not a finding of incapacity.

That boundary comes from how South African law sorts workplace problems. The Labour Relations Act recognises conduct, capacity and operational requirements as different reasons an employer may rely on for a dismissal, and item 5(2) of the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal of 4 September 2025 repeats those three grounds. Misconduct has its own part of the Code, Part D. Poor work performance sits under capacity, in Part F. Draftly's instructions treat a “not met” rating against an objective as an observation about the work, not as a finding under either part.

So the review is drafted without the vocabulary of discipline. Draftly is told never to use the “in that” charge convention, never to adopt the language of a warning, and never to treat sustained weak results as an offence. If the wording you supply drifts that way, it is told to flag it on the review panel instead of carrying it into the document.

Why the wording matters later

A review is read more than once.

On the day, the review is a conversation. Later it can become evidence of what the employer knew and said at the time. Item 19(1)(a) of the Code names appropriate evaluation first in its list of what an employer should give before dismissing someone for unsatisfactory performance after probation, alongside instruction, training, guidance and counselling. Where a required standard was not met, item 20(1) asks, among other things, whether the employee was aware, or could reasonably be expected to have been aware, of that standard.

A review does not settle either question, and this page does not suggest that one review discharges anything in item 19. What it can do is show, in a document dated at the time, which objectives were set, how each was rated and why. That only helps if it is accurate. If every review on a file says the employee is comfortably meeting expectations and a formal process about performance then begins, the file contradicts itself.

The same applies in the other direction. A rating that is harsher than the evidence behind it, or a comment about someone's personality rather than their work, is unfair to the employee and exposes the employer to a complaint about the review itself. Draftly's rules for this document ask for neither an inflated account nor an unduly severe one: a balanced summary, tied to what was observed.

Ratings that hold up

Evidence first, adjectives last.

Each objective on the form is rated Met, Partially met or Not met, with a comment beside it. The comment is where the rating earns its place. “Not a team player” tells the employee nothing they can act on. “Two of the four monthly supplier reconciliations were submitted after the agreed cut-off, and the finance team chased both” is specific, checkable and fair to dispute if it is wrong.

Draftly is told to ground every rating and comment in objective, observable, job-related performance over the period under review, and to flag a rating or comment that rests on personality or unsupported opinion. It is also told to record strengths as well as development areas, so the document reflects the whole period rather than only what fell short.

Consistency matters as much as accuracy. Assess each person against the standards you apply to others in a comparable role. Draftly's instructions name the Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 and tell it to avoid criteria or wording that could be discriminatory, such as anything relating to a ground the law protects. They also keep out the employee's ID number, home address and medical information: a review needs none of them.

When results fall short

Record the gap, then the way forward.

A review that rates an objective as not met, or gives a below-standard overall rating, should not stop there. The goals and action plan section exists for exactly this: what the employee will work on next period and what the employer will provide, whether that is training, closer supervision, equipment or a clearer brief. Draftly is told to flag a below-standard review that records no goals, support or action plan for improvement.

Where the shortfall is sustained and may need to be dealt with formally, that is a separate track. The review is not where it happens. Draftly's instructions point to the poor-work-performance process under Part F and tell it to flag the matter for that process, not to turn the review into a first step towards dismissal. The performance improvement plan page covers that document.

Item 19 is written for employees who have completed probation. For someone still on probation, the Code's Part E applies: item 17 expects reasonable guidance during probation, and item 18(1) requires the employer to hear the employee's representations before deciding to dismiss or to extend the probationary period. A review of a probationer can still be useful, but read Part E before relying on one in a probation decision.

What the review holds

Eight sections and two signatures.

Draftly's instructions lay the review out as follows:

  • Review details: the employee's name, position and department, the period covered, the reviewing manager and the date of the review.
  • An overall summary of the period, written to be neither inflated nor unduly harsh.
  • Each objective or KPI, with its rating and a factual comment grounded in observable performance.
  • Strengths: what the employee did well, stated as fact.
  • Areas for development, framed as growth and kept to the job.
  • Goals and an action plan for the next period, including any support, training or resources the employer will provide.
  • The overall rating, tied to the objectives above and expressed on a clear, consistent scale.
  • An acknowledgement that the review was conducted and discussed with the employee, who may add their own comments.

The reviewing manager signs with their name, role and the date. The employee signs an acknowledgement block that sets out what that signature means: the review was received and discussed. It does not mean the employee agrees with it, and Draftly is told to say so. There is space for the employee's comments. If they write on the printed copy, file that copy, because the version Draftly holds only contains what you entered.

Drafting it with Draftly

What the form asks you for.

The person being reviewed comes first, either selected from your directory or entered with their name, employee number and position. After that, three review fields must be completed before Generate is enabled:

  • Review period: the span of work the review covers, for example a named quarter.
  • Reviewing manager: the person who conducted the review and signs it.
  • At least one objective: add a row for every objective or KPI, each with its rating and comment.

Everything else is optional: the manager's role, strengths, areas for development, goals and an action plan for the next period, an overall rating in your own words, general comments, and the language of the document. Leaving the goals empty on a weak review is the gap Draftly is told to point out, so fill it in whenever any objective was missed.

A review is one of the documents Draftly will draft without your disciplinary code on file. It is not stored as a warning, so it carries no expiry and plays no part in any warning history. Matched to an employee in your directory, it is saved to that person's record alongside their other documents.

Flags, where there are any, appear on an internal review panel on the final page of both the Word and PDF versions. That page is marked as not for the employee, so remove it before the review is handed over.

For employers

Draft the performance review from your facts.

Draftly drafts the performance review from the facts you enter. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.

What this page will not do

It explains what a performance review is for, how it differs from a warning or a poor-performance process, and what Draftly asks for. It does not set a review cycle or rating scale, list the grounds protected by employment equity law, or say whether any later dismissal would be fair.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.