Skip to main content
Draftly for employers
Employer document

Reference letters in South Africa.

Someone who works for you, or used to, has an offer pending, and the new employer wants something from you in writing. A stranger is about to make a hiring decision partly on your words, and the person you are writing about may well read them too. That is two readers who can each be let down, in opposite directions, and the letter has to be fair to both.

True in both directions

Too harsh and too kind both cost you.

The obvious risk is the damaging remark. Draftly's rules for this letter forbid subjective negative characterisation and opinion that cannot be substantiated, and they give the reason plainly: defamation risk. A word like “unreliable” or “difficult” is a judgement about a person, not a fact about the job.

The less obvious risk runs the other way. The same rules warn that a misleadingly favourable reference can create liability too, and tell Draftly not to overstate. If your records do not support “an outstanding performer”, the letter should not say it.

The test Draftly's rules apply to each sentence is the same either way: is it true, and could you show the record it rests on? Dates of service, the job title and what the role involved pass that test easily. Adjectives about character usually do not.

Performance and conduct

A comment only when asked for, and only on the facts.

A comment on how the person worked is optional. On the form it sits behind a checkbox, and if you leave that unticked, Draftly is told to drop the performance and conduct section from the letter entirely. It is also told to omit it when you tick the box but give nothing that supports a comment.

When you do want one, the box beneath the checkbox is for the facts behind it, not the adjectives: targets met, responsibilities carried, the absence of any disciplinary record during service if that is true. The form itself warns that Draftly flags subjective or unsupported claims. A favourable line with nothing in your input to support it is something Draftly is told to flag as an overstated reference.

If the material you give is negative, Draftly's instructions are to keep it strictly factual and raise a flag on it for you to look at. A negative fact is not forbidden; a negative opinion presented as a fact is the problem. Whether to include it at all is your decision, and leaving the box unticked is always open to you.

Why they left

Neutral, or left out.

The reason for leaving is also optional. Leave the box blank and, as the form puts it, the reason is omitted entirely. If you fill it in, Draftly is told to state it neutrally and factually. The form's own example is “resigned to pursue other employment”, not an account of who was to blame.

Where the employment ended in dismissal, the instruction is the same: say what happened, factually, and do not editorialise. A reference is not the place to argue the case again. A reference letter makes no finding under the Labour Relations Act or the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal; it records an outcome that was reached elsewhere, if you choose to record it at all.

Certificate of service

When the reference is also the certificate.

Draftly uses this one document type for both a reference and a certificate of service, the record issued when employment ends. For that second use, Draftly's instructions name section 42 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act and list the particulars to include: the employee's full name, the employer, the dates employment began and ended, and, if the employee asks, their remuneration and the reason the employment ended.

The form collects the dates and the reason. It has no field for remuneration, so check the draft against that list before you hand it over. For a person who has not left, tick the box saying they are still employed and the end date stops being required.

What the letter contains

Five parts, two of them optional.

The rule pack sets out the body in this order:

  • Employment details: full name, job title, department, the first and last day of service (or a statement that the person still works for you) and the total period worked.
  • Duties and responsibilities: a factual summary of the role, based only on what you typed.
  • Performance and conduct, present only when you asked for it and gave facts to support it.
  • Reason for leaving, present only when you filled it in.
  • A closing paragraph stating the letter is issued at the employee's request or for their records, with a contact who can verify it.

The rule pack adds a block headed “issued by”, for the signing manager, and a line for the company stamp. Draftly is told never to put a finding, a sanction or the “in that” drafting convention that charge sheets use into the letter; the rules treat this as a neutral record of employment. Draftly is also told to leave personal details out: the rule pack names the employee's identity number and residential address as data a reference has no use for, and a draft that carries them is flagged.

Drafting it with Draftly

Three required fields, plus the employee.

The employee is required first: choose them from your directory, or enter their name, employee number and position by hand. Then these have to be filled in before the letter can be generated:

  • Employment start date: when service began.
  • Issuing manager name: whoever signs the letter.
  • Employment end date: needed unless you tick that the employee is still employed.

The duties box is optional but carries most of the letter's substance. The form's hint says it is used verbatim as the basis for the letter, and the rule pack tells Draftly to summarise the role from it and nothing else, so write what the person actually did. The manager's role, a verification contact such as an HR email address and the letter's language are optional as well.

No uploaded disciplinary code is needed for a reference, since nothing in it is drawn from one. If a check trips, the flag sits on a review page at the end of the Word and PDF files, written for you and not for the employee or the new employer. Take that page out before the reference goes anywhere. For a letter that only confirms a current employee's job, see the confirmation of employment page.

For employers

Draft the reference letter from your facts.

Draftly drafts the reference letter from the facts you enter. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.

What this page will not do

It explains what Draftly puts in a reference letter and what it keeps out. It does not say whether you must give a reference, what section 42 requires in law, or how a court would treat a particular statement in one.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.