Skip to main content
Draftly for employers
Employer document

Verbal warnings in South Africa.

A verbal warning is given out loud, in a conversation, and then written down. The conversation is the warning. The document is the manager's note that the conversation happened. This page explains why that difference matters, what the note should hold, and what Draftly's verbal warning form asks you for.

Spoken, then recorded

You do not serve a verbal warning. You record it.

There are two very different documents an employer could produce here. One is a letter that replaces the conversation: a page headed “verbal warning”, handed over instead of talking. At that point the warning is no longer verbal in any useful sense, and the employee may fairly ask why a written document arrived for what is usually the lightest step in a disciplinary code. The other is a record of a conversation that has already happened.

Keep the two apart. The manager talks to the employee first: what happened, why it is a problem, and what has to change. Afterwards, the manager writes a record of that discussion and places it on file. Draftly's document for this is called a verbal warning record for exactly that reason. It is not drafted as an instrument handed to the employee in place of the talk. It is the manager's own account, made close to the time, of a talk that already took place.

The employee is still shown the record and asked to acknowledge it. What they sign confirms that the discussion happened on the stated date. The wording Draftly uses says plainly that signing is not an admission of wrongdoing, and the record has a line for a witness in case the employee declines.

Where it sits

The first formal step, not the first conversation.

Item 6 of the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, published in September 2025, describes discipline as corrective and applied in stages. It also says that formal procedures need not be used every time a rule is broken, and that informal advice is often the best answer to a minor issue. A verbal warning is not that informal advice. It is a recorded step on the employee's file, and it carries consequences that a quiet word does not.

The Labour Relations Act does not define a verbal warning or say where it ranks. Your own disciplinary code does. A code may put it at the bottom of the ladder, below a written warning, and reserve it for conduct that is minor or happening for the first time. Before you give one, check that your code lists the conduct and allows a verbal warning for it. If the code would send this conduct straight to a written warning or further, a verbal warning is the wrong tool.

What the record holds

Conversational, but specific.

A verbal warning record is short and plain. It should not read like a charge sheet: there is no formal allegation and no “in that” wording. It should still be precise enough that a person reading the file a year later understands what happened without asking anyone.

  • The date of the incident, and separately the date of the discussion, since the two can be days apart.
  • A short factual account of the conduct, in neutral language, without adjectives about the employee's character.
  • Confirmation that a discussion took place, what was covered in it, and what the employee was told to do differently.
  • How long the warning stays on record, taken from your disciplinary code, and that it is spent once that period runs out.
  • What may follow if the conduct continues: the next step your code allows, usually one rung up and no further.
  • The name and role of the manager who gave it, and the signatures or the witness note.

On escalation, the record should name only what your code permits as the next step. Threatening a final warning or dismissal in a verbal warning record, where the code would not allow it, undermines the corrective purpose and gives the employee something to dispute.

Why bother writing it down

An unrecorded warning is hard to rely on.

The 2025 Code's item 13 deals with disciplinary records: what the employee did wrong, what the employer did about it, and why. A conversation nobody noted down leaves all three blank. If the conduct happens again and the next step depends on an earlier verbal warning, the employer needs to show that the warning was given, when, and for what.

Item 9 of the Code counts the employee's disciplinary record among the factors in deciding whether dismissal is appropriate. A verbal warning is usually far from that point, but it is where the record starts, and a clean, dated note is worth more later than a manager's memory of what they said.

If the employee disagrees

The lightest step can still be challenged.

Being the mildest sanction does not put a verbal warning beyond challenge. Once it is on file it is disciplinary action, and the Labour Relations Act lists unfairness in disciplinary action short of dismissal among unfair labour practices, in section 186(2)(b). An employee who thinks the warning unfair can take it to the CCMA, or to a bargaining council if one covers the workplace, within 90 days of the act complained of. If the employee only learnt of the warning later, section 191(1)(b)(ii) runs the period from then instead: within 90 days of becoming aware of it.

In practice, the bigger risk is that an employee's disagreement goes unrecorded. If they dispute the facts during the discussion, note that in the record. If your code provides a way to object or appeal, tell them about it and keep what they submit with the record.

Drafting it with Draftly

What the form asks for.

Draftly's verbal warning form starts with the employee's name, employee number and position. Beyond those it requires five things:

  • Date of incident: when the conduct happened.
  • What did they do?: a brief factual description, which the record keeps conversational.
  • Conduct category: the family of conduct from a fixed list, used to track related warnings over time.
  • Date of verbal warning discussion: when you actually spoke to the employee.
  • Issuing manager name: who gave the warning.

Optional fields cover the improvement you expect, the manager's role and the validity period in months. That period starts at three, which is only the form's starting value and not a rule from the Act or the Code. Change it to whatever your own code sets. Draftly also needs your disciplinary code loaded on the account before it drafts, because the record names the next step your code permits.

If you select the employee from your directory, the record is filed against them under the conduct category, with the date it lapses. While it is still active, a later verbal, written or final warning for the same employee in the same category supersedes it, provided that later warning is also linked to the employee in your directory and given a category. A record that has already lapsed is left as it is.

If the conduct carries on after the warning, the written warning page covers the next rung, and the warnings guide covers the ladder as a whole.

For employers

Draft the verbal warning record from your facts.

Draftly drafts the verbal warning record from the facts you enter and your own disciplinary code. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.

What this page will not do

It explains the difference between giving a verbal warning and recording one, and what the record should hold. It does not decide whether a given incident calls for a verbal warning, or how long one should last. Your disciplinary code sets both.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.