Notice of an appeal hearing in South Africa.
The enquiry is over, the employee has received its outcome, and they have put an appeal in writing. This notice is the employer's reply: it confirms the appeal has arrived, sets out what the employee says went wrong, and calls them to a hearing before a chairperson Draftly expects to outrank the first. Below: what the notice contains, the habits that keep an appeal clean, and why it must not be confused with a CCMA referral.
A second look, not a second trial.
An internal appeal exists because your disciplinary code, or an agreement that binds you, provides for one. Neither the Labour Relations Act nor the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, in the text Draftly has checked, says an employer must offer it, and this page makes no such claim. Where your code does offer an appeal, the notice is the first proof that you treated it as real: it names the decision under challenge, records the objections, and says who will decide them.
Draftly's drafting instructions frame the appeal as a fresh look at the grounds the employee raised, rather than a rerun of the whole enquiry from the first witness. If your code gives appeals a wider scope, your code governs, and the Word file can be edited to say so before it is served.
What a later reader will ask.
A dismissal that reaches the CCMA is tested under section 188(1) of the Labour Relations Act: was there a fair reason, and was a fair procedure followed? Section 192 puts the burden of proving fairness on the employer once the employee shows they were dismissed. An appeal hearing is part of the record a commissioner may read when asking those questions. This page does not say that an appeal can cure a flawed enquiry; it says only that a badly run appeal adds a second set of problems to the file.
Item 11 of the Code describes what should usually happen before a decision to dismiss: the employee learns what is alleged, gets reasonable time to prepare, may be assisted by a fellow employee or union representative, and where reasonably possible may use a language they are comfortable with. That item is written around the first decision. Draftly's appeal notice lists similar rights for the appeal stage because its instructions ask for them; whether your code requires them there is for your code to say.
Appeals are not only about dismissals. Where your code allows it, an employee may also appeal a final written warning or another lesser sanction, and section 186(2)(b) treats unfair disciplinary action short of dismissal as an unfair labour practice. Give an appeal against a warning the same care as one against the loss of a job.
Five sections, then a receipt.
The drafting instructions set the notice out in this sequence:
- Appeal details: when the original outcome was given and what sanction it imposed, the date the appeal was lodged, and the date, time and venue of the appeal hearing with the name of its chairperson.
- The grounds of appeal, reproduced as the employee gave them.
- The scope of the appeal: what the chairperson will consider and the three results open to them.
- The employee's rights at the appeal: assistance by a fellow employee or shop steward, the chance to present evidence and call witnesses, to question the other side's witnesses, an interpreter if one is needed, and a written closing statement.
- Attendance: that the employee is required to be there, and what may follow if they stay away, read with the appeal procedure in your own code.
After the last section, the instructions ask for two places to sign: an acknowledgement of receipt that the employee signs and dates, and a block where a witness can confirm delivery if the employee declines to sign. Because the instructions head the employee's block as an acknowledgement of receipt, signing it confirms only that the notice arrived.
In the employee's words, not yours.
The form asks for the grounds of appeal as the employee stated them, and the hint under the box says Draftly will not interpret or judge them. The instructions behind the draft say the same: the grounds appear as given, never characterised or assessed. Paste them from the appeal letter, or summarise them closely if the letter is long, keeping each ground as a separate point.
There is a reason for being strict about this. If the notice restates a ground in softer or narrower terms, the employee can say afterwards that the appeal chairperson decided an appeal they never lodged. Quoting the grounds faithfully leaves no room for that complaint to start, and it costs nothing.
Confirm, vary or set aside.
The instructions have the notice tell the employee what the appeal can achieve: the original sanction may be confirmed, varied, or set aside. Draftly is instructed to keep to those three words and to avoid language that signals the answer in advance, such as a line about upholding the dismissal. A notice that reads as if the decision is already made invites the argument that the appeal was a formality.
When the sanction being appealed is dismissal, the instructions ask for a sentence saying the dismissal stands while the appeal is pending unless the appeal chairperson rules otherwise. Whether the employee is paid during that time is left to your disciplinary code; the notice is told to defer to it rather than state a rule of its own. Read that paragraph against your code before you serve the notice.
Someone more senior.
The form says plainly that the appeal chairperson must be more senior than whoever chaired the original enquiry. That is Draftly's rule for this document, carried in its drafting instructions, and this page does not attribute it to the Act or the Code. The draft is instructed to raise a flag if you enter the same person, or someone it can tell is of equal or lower rank.
That check can only work with what you give it. The original chairperson's name is optional on the form and there is no field for that person's rank, so a blank name leaves Draftly with nothing to compare. Fill it in. Even then, without the original chairperson's rank the check can only catch the same name, so confirm seniority yourself. Any flag lands on the internal review panel, printed as the final page of both the Word and the PDF file and marked for the employer only; remove it before the notice reaches the employee.
The instructions also carry a default amount of notice for the appeal hearing, counted in working days, and ask for a flag when the date you enter leaves less. That default is a product setting. Where your code fixes its own notice for appeals, follow the code and adjust the draft.
Separate routes, separate clocks.
The internal appeal lives inside your disciplinary code or the agreement that provides for it, which decides how it is lodged, who hears it and on what timetable. A referral to the CCMA or a bargaining council is governed by the Labour Relations Act instead. Draftly's appeal notice deals only with the first of these: none of its sections is about the CCMA.
For a dismissal, section 191(1)(b)(i) fixes the referral period. The dispute must be referred within 30 days of the date of dismissal. The section also names a later starting point: where the employer only reaches its final decision, to dismiss or to uphold a dismissal, after that date, the period is counted from that decision instead. This page does not say how an internal appeal affects that date; take advice if the timing matters in your case.
A disputed warning or other sanction short of dismissal is an unfair labour practice question under section 191(1)(b)(ii), and its period is longer. The employee must refer it within 90 days of the act complained of, and an employee who only finds out about the act later must refer within 90 days of becoming aware of it.
The fields you must fill.
Pick the employee from your directory or type in their name, employee number and position, and then complete the six fields marked as required:
- Original outcome date: the day the result now being appealed was given.
- Original sanction imposed: as recorded, for example a final written warning with its validity, or a dismissal with its effective date.
- Grounds of appeal (as stated by employee): taken from the appeal letter, not reworded.
- Date: when the appeal hearing will sit.
- Venue: the room or address at which the appeal will sit.
- Appeal chairperson name: the more senior person who will hear the appeal.
Worth completing as well: the original chairperson, the date the appeal was lodged, the hearing time (the field is pre-filled with 10:00, so change it if needed), the appeal chairperson's role, and the HR representative with their role. As with the other disciplinary documents, the form needs a disciplinary code loaded on your account before it will generate.
The appeal notice follows the outcome letter, and the CCMA referral guide explains what happens if the dispute goes outside the company.
Draft the appeal hearing notice from your facts.
Draftly drafts the appeal hearing notice from the facts you enter and your own disciplinary code. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.
- Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995, sections 186(2)(b) (unfair labour practice), 188(1) (fair reason and fair procedure), 191(1)(b)(i) and (ii) (time limits for referral) and 192 (onus).
- Code of Good Practice: Dismissal (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294, 4 September 2025), item 11 (fair procedure).
Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.
What this page will not do
It covers the notice that calls an employee to an internal disciplinary appeal. It does not say whether your code must offer an appeal, how long an employee has to lodge one, how much notice of an appeal hearing is enough, who is senior enough to chair it, or whether pay continues while a dismissal is under appeal.
Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.