Skip to main content
Draftly for employers
Employer document

Disciplinary outcome letter in South Africa.

The enquiry has ended and the chairperson has reached a decision. The outcome letter carries it to the employee: every charge with its finding, the sanction and the date it takes effect, and the routes open to them if they disagree. Below: what the letter records, the line it must not cross, and the fields Draftly's form asks you for.

A report, not a ruling

The chairperson decides. The letter reports.

This document has a narrow job. It does not weigh evidence and it does not choose a penalty; both of those happened in the room. What it does is put the conclusions of the person who chaired the enquiry into words the employee can follow, and that a commissioner can follow too if the matter is referred later.

Draftly's form opens by saying so, and the drafting instructions behind it say it again: Draftly formats what you report, and the instructions tell it never to suggest, predict or invent a finding or a sanction. Enter what the chairperson concluded as it was recorded, not as you would have put it yourself.

That restraint protects the employer. A letter that adds a reason nobody gave at the enquiry, or firms a sanction up into something harsher, creates a second account of the result. Where the two differ, the employee can point at the gap, and you are left arguing about which version was the real decision.

How it fits the law

Reasons set down in one place.

When a dismissal is challenged, section 188(1) of the Labour Relations Act asks the employer to prove a fair reason and a fair procedure, and section 192 settles who carries that burden: once the employee shows there was a dismissal, it falls to the employer to show the dismissal was fair. The outcome letter is a document that sets the reasons for the result down together, close to the time.

The Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, gazetted in September 2025, shapes what those reasons should cover. Item 8 sets out what a decision-maker looks at in judging a sanction, running from whether a valid rule existed and was known, through the harm the breach caused, to whether dismissal fits at all. Item 9 treats dismissal as generally appropriate only where continuing the employment relationship has become intolerable. Item 10 looks for the same rule to be applied the same way across employees. A letter that records the mitigating and aggravating factors the chairperson weighed lets a later reader see that this weighing took place.

Not every outcome is a dismissal. A warning or another disciplinary step that ends the hearing can still be disputed: section 186(2)(b) treats unfair disciplinary action short of dismissal as an unfair labour practice, so the letter matters as much when the employee keeps their job.

What goes in it

Six sections and three signatures.

Draftly's drafting instructions lay the letter out in this order:

  • The hearing itself: its date and venue, who chaired, and who presented the employer's case.
  • Each charge as originally framed, the finding on it and, where it was proven, the chairperson's brief reasons.
  • The sanction, reproduced exactly as you entered it, together with its effective date.
  • Why that sanction: the mitigating and aggravating factors considered and the reasoning for choosing it.
  • The right of appeal internally, and the separate referral route to the CCMA if the employee is still dissatisfied.
  • Implementation: when the sanction starts to apply and, for a dismissal, a paragraph on final pay and notice arrangements. The form has no field for these, so check that paragraph against what you have actually arranged.

The same instructions call for three signature blocks at the end. The chairperson signs and dates. The employee signs an acknowledgement worded so that it confirms receipt only and does not amount to accepting the findings or the sanction. A witness line covers the case where the employee will not sign.

The findings

Guilty, not guilty or withdrawn.

The form gives each charge three possible findings and no fourth. Where a charge was proven, the letter uses the reasoning you enter for it and is instructed to add nothing of its own. Where it was not, the letter is instructed to note briefly that it was not proven. Where the initiator dropped it, it is instructed to note that the charge was withdrawn at or before the enquiry.

Copy each allegation across from the original charge sheet word for word. If the outcome describes a charge differently from the way it was put, the employee can say they were found guilty of something they were never asked to answer, and item 11 of the Code says that, before a decision to dismiss, an employee should usually know what is alleged against them. The letter should show plainly that the finding answers the same allegation.

List every charge that was heard, including any that failed. A record that leaves out the charges that went the employee's way reads as selective.

The sanction

In the chairperson's own words.

The sanction is a free-text box with a short instruction underneath it: type the sanction exactly as the chairperson recorded it, because Draftly does not suggest one. If the record names a final written warning with a stated validity, the instructions are to repeat that type and period as entered, not a paraphrase of them; check that the draft did.

Draftly is also instructed to raise a flag where the facts you supply suggest the sanction is out of proportion to the findings, while leaving the sanction in the letter exactly as entered. Any flag appears on the internal review panel, the last page of both the Word and the PDF file, marked as not for distribution to the employee. Remove that page before you serve the letter. Treat a flag as a reason to check with the chairperson, not as a second opinion on the case.

One product limit is worth knowing. When the sanction is a warning, the outcome letter reports it but is not one of Draftly's warning documents, so it sets no validity date and does not supersede earlier warnings on the employee's profile. If you rely on that tracking, record the warning with its own document as well.

Appeal and referral

Two routes, two clocks.

The drafting instructions require the letter to explain an internal appeal: lodged in writing, with its grounds stated, and addressed to the appeal authority you name on the form, which starts as the Managing Director. The time allowed for lodging it comes from those instructions rather than from any field you fill in, and it is Draftly's default, not a figure taken from the Act or the Code. If your disciplinary code allows a different period, correct it in the Word file before the letter is served.

The instructions also require the letter to mention the CCMA, which is a separate route with time limits of its own, set by the Act rather than by your code. For a dismissal, section 191(1)(b)(i) requires the dispute to be referred within 30 days of the date of dismissal. Where the employer makes its final decision to dismiss, or to uphold the dismissal, on a later date, the 30-day period is counted from that decision instead.

A warning or another lesser sanction disputed as an unfair labour practice falls under section 191(1)(b)(ii), and that period is longer: the referral is due within 90 days of the act complained of. Where the employee learns of the act only afterwards, it is due within 90 days of becoming aware of it.

Drafting it with Draftly

The fields you must fill.

Choose the employee from your directory or enter them by name, employee number and position, and then complete the six fields the form marks as required:

  • Hearing date: when the enquiry was held.
  • Chairperson name: the person whose decision the letter reports, who also signs it.
  • At least one charge: the allegation as it was originally put to the employee.
  • Finding: guilty, not guilty or withdrawn for that charge. It starts on guilty, so check it.
  • Sanction (verbatim): the penalty in the chairperson's own wording.
  • Sanction effective date: the day it begins to apply.

The rest is optional but worth filling in: the venue, the chairperson's role, the initiator and their role, a short note of reasoning under each charge, the mitigating and aggravating factors, why this sanction was chosen, and the appeal authority. Fields you leave blank give the letter less to report. This form will only generate once your account has a disciplinary code loaded.

The outcome letter comes after the notice of hearing, and the fair dismissal guide covers the reason-and-procedure test in more depth.

For employers

Draft the outcome letter from your facts.

Draftly drafts the outcome letter from the facts you enter and your own disciplinary code. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.

What this page will not do

It covers the letter that reports the result of a disciplinary enquiry. It does not say whether your code must offer an internal appeal, how long an appeal period should be, which sanction suits a given finding, or what is owed to an employee on leaving.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.