Skip to main content
All guides
Discipline guide

A fair dismissal.

Under the Labour Relations Act a dismissal is fair only if it is for a fair reason and follows a fair procedure, and it is the employer that has to prove both. This guide sets out what that means, with the focus on dismissal for misconduct.

FreeNo account, no emailNothing to fill in

There is nothing to fill in on this page. No account, no email address and no form. It reads the same for every visitor, and nothing on it asks you for anything.

The test

Fair reason and fair procedure.

Section 188 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 says a dismissal that is not automatically unfair is unfair if the employer fails to prove that the reason was a fair one, related to the employee's conduct or capacity or based on the employer's operational requirements, and that the dismissal was carried out in accordance with a fair procedure. Both halves are needed. A good reason does not rescue a bad process.

Item 5 of the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal puts the same rule plainly and names the three grounds: the employee's conduct, the employee's capacity, and the employer's operational requirements. The Code deals with each in its own part: misconduct in Part D, incapacity in Part F and operational requirements in Part G. This guide deals with misconduct.

Who proves what

The burden is on the employer.

Section 192 of the Act says that in a dismissal dispute the employee must first establish that there was a dismissal. Once that is established, the employer must prove that the dismissal was fair.

That is why the paperwork matters. The employer will be the one asked to show what the allegation was, that the employee was told of it and had a chance to answer, and why dismissal was the sanction.

Automatically unfair

Some reasons are automatically unfair.

Section 187 of the Act lists reasons that make a dismissal automatically unfair, whatever procedure was followed. They include reasons that infringe employees' and trade unions' rights and forms of discrimination. If the real reason for a dismissal is one of those, following a fair procedure does not make it fair. Section 187(2) carries narrow exceptions for the discrimination grounds: a dismissal may be fair if the reason is based on an inherent requirement of the particular job, and a dismissal based on age is fair if the employee has reached the normal or agreed retirement age. Read section 187 itself rather than relying on a summary.

Misconduct

When dismissal is the right sanction.

Item 7 of the Code says dismissal for misconduct is for serious misconduct that makes a continued employment relationship intolerable. That can be a single serious incident, or a pattern of repeated conduct where graduated disciplinary measures, such as warnings, have already been applied.

Item 9 says dismissal is generally appropriate only if a continued employment relationship is intolerable, and lists factors to consider in deciding that:

  • the nature and requirements of the job;
  • the nature and seriousness of the misconduct and its effect on the business;
  • whether progressive discipline might prevent it happening again;
  • any acknowledgement of wrongdoing by the employee, and willingness to comply with the rules; and
  • the employee's circumstances, including length of service, disciplinary record and the effect of dismissal on them.

The procedure before the decision is in item 11, covered in the disciplinary hearing guide. How earlier warnings feed into this is in the written warning guide.

If it is disputed

The 30-day window.

An employee who disputes the fairness of a dismissal may refer it to the CCMA or the relevant bargaining council within 30 days of the date of dismissal, or within 30 days of the employer's final decision to dismiss or uphold the dismissal if that is later (section 191(1)(b)(i)). A late referral can still be allowed if the employee shows good cause (section 191(2)).

See the CCMA referral guide for what happens next.

For employers

This guide explains the process. Draftly drafts the documents.

Draftly drafts the notice of hearing, the outcome letter and the appeal hearing notice from the facts you enter, in line with South African labour law. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Checked against the text of the Act and the Code in October 2026. The Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Gazette 53294, Notice 3470) repealed and replaced the earlier Schedule 8 Code. Its items are numbered differently, so an item number taken from a guide written before September 2025 may not point at the same provision today. The item numbers on this page are the 2025 ones.

What this guide will not do

It explains when the Act treats a dismissal as fair. It does not tell you whether a particular dismissal was fair, what a dispute would be worth, or how the CCMA would decide it — those turn on the facts. Where a matter is serious or complex, speak to a labour practitioner.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.