Skip to main content
Draftly for employers
Employer document

Incapacity hearings in South Africa.

Some employees cannot do the job to the level it needs, either because their work keeps falling short or because illness or injury stands in the way. An incapacity enquiry is the formal meeting where that is examined with them. The notice tells the employee it is happening, what it is about, and what it is not.

Ability, not blame

A question about capacity, never a charge.

The Labour Relations Act allows a dismissal to be fair for a reason connected with the employee's conduct, their capacity or the employer's operational requirements, and the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal of September 2025 restates that trio in item 5(2). It then gives each its own treatment: misconduct in Part D, incapacity in Part F. For an employee who has completed probation, an incapacity enquiry is a Part F matter.

The practical consequence is in the wording. A misconduct notice alleges that someone broke a rule. An incapacity notice alleges nothing of the kind; it describes a gap between what the role requires and what the employee is currently able to deliver, and invites them to help work out what can be done about it. Draftly's rules for this notice forbid the “in that” charge formula and any framing of the matter as guilt or wrongdoing.

Sometimes facts that arrive as “incapacity” are really something else: a refusal, carelessness, a choice. Where what you describe reads as wilful or negligent conduct rather than inability, Draftly is told to flag on the review panel that a disciplinary hearing may be the right process instead. The notice of hearing page covers that route.

Two routes

Performance or health: pick one.

The form makes you choose between poor work performance and ill health or injury, and the notice is written differently for each. They answer different questions. A performance enquiry asks whether the employee can reach a known standard given fair help. A health enquiry asks how serious and how lasting the condition is, and whether the work can be arranged around it.

The heading of item 21 also speaks of “other forms of incapacity”. This notice does not offer a third option for those. If the situation fits neither poor performance nor ill health, take advice before using it.

Poor work performance

What the enquiry has to look at.

Item 19 is about employees who have completed probation. Its starting point is that someone should not be dismissed for unsatisfactory work unless the employer first evaluated, instructed, trained, guided or counselled them, as appropriate, and allowed a reasonable time to improve, after which the work was still unsatisfactory. Item 19(2) adds that the employee should get to answer the allegations of unsatisfactory performance before any dismissal. The enquiry is where that answer is heard.

Item 20(1) is written for the person who later judges the fairness of such a dismissal. It asks first whether a performance standard was actually missed and, if so, four more things: did the employee know of the standard, or could they reasonably have been expected to; did they get a fair opportunity to meet it; was it reasonably achievable; and was dismissal an appropriate response to the shortfall. A well-run enquiry gathers evidence on every one of those before anyone decides anything.

That is why the “steps already taken” field matters so much on the performance route. An enquiry called without any record of evaluation, coaching or time to improve has little to show for item 19. If that groundwork has not been done yet, the performance improvement plan page describes the document that usually comes first. For an employee still on probation, Part E applies rather than item 19, and the probation outcome page covers it.

Ill health or injury

Investigate, accommodate, consider alternatives.

Item 21(1) recognises that physical or mental ill health or injury may be temporary or permanent. Where an employee is temporarily unable to work, the employer should find out how serious the incapacity or injury is. Where the absence is likely to run for a time that is unreasonably long in the circumstances, the employer should explore every alternative short of dismissal, weighing factors that include the nature of the job, how long the employee will be away, how serious the condition is, and whether a temporary replacement can be found.

For permanent incapacity, item 21(2) points the employer towards other work the employee could do, or towards changing their duties or working conditions to accommodate the disability. Item 21(3) gives the employee, during the investigation, a chance to put their side and to be assisted by a trade union representative or a fellow employee. Items 21(1) to 21(3) put no figure on how long an absence must last before it becomes unreasonably long, and this page does not guess.

Health information is sensitive. Draftly's general rules keep medical details out of its documents unless they are needed and you have supplied them. On this route the nature of the condition is the subject of the enquiry, so describe what bears on the job and the absence pattern, and leave the rest of the medical record where it is.

Inside the notice

Six headings and a receipt.

Draftly's instructions arrange the incapacity notice under these headings:

  • Enquiry details: when and where it takes place, who chairs it, and which type of incapacity is under consideration.
  • The nature of the incapacity, stated neutrally: shortfalls against known standards, or the health or injury position.
  • Steps already taken, as a numbered list drawn from what you enter.
  • The purpose of the enquiry: to assess the extent of the problem, whether the employee can be helped or accommodated, and what alternatives exist.
  • The employee's rights at the enquiry, including representation by a fellow employee or shop steward, presenting evidence (medical evidence included), an interpreter where needed, and being heard before any decision.
  • A closing note that the employee must attend, and what may follow if they do not.

The possible outcomes the notice describes run from continued support or other arrangements through to, only as a last resort, termination on the ground of incapacity. Draftly is told never to present ending the employment as a foregone conclusion. Two blocks follow the text: an acknowledgement of receipt for the employee, and a witness block for use if they decline to sign.

If it ends the employment

A dismissal like any other.

Termination for incapacity is still a dismissal under section 186(1)(a) of the Labour Relations Act, and section 188 still asks for a fair reason and a fair procedure, taking the Code into account. An employee who disputes it can refer the matter to the CCMA or a bargaining council within 30 days of the date of dismissal, under section 191(1)(b)(i); where the employer only takes its final decision to dismiss, or to uphold the dismissal, after that date, the period is counted from the decision instead. The notice does not decide any of this. It opens a process whose fairness will be judged on what actually happens in the room and afterwards.

Drafting it with Draftly

What the form will ask.

The employee comes first. If they are already in your directory, select them; if not, enter their name, employee number and position by hand. Six further fields block generation until they are filled:

  • Type of incapacity: poor work performance or ill health / injury. It starts on poor work performance, so switch it for a health matter.
  • Describe the performance shortfalls against the required standard: the standard and how the work measures against it, with examples and dates. On the health route this box is labelled for the ill-health or injury position and the pattern of absence instead.
  • Date: the day of the enquiry.
  • Time: pre-filled with 10:00, so check it.
  • Venue: where the enquiry will sit.
  • Initiator name: who will set out the facts for the employer at the enquiry.

Steps already taken, the chairperson, the initiator's role and the document language are optional. Draftly needs your disciplinary code loaded on the account before it drafts this notice, even though incapacity is not a disciplinary matter. Its general instructions also tell it to apply the procedural provisions of your own code first, such as representation rights, where the code has them.

Because this notice is not filed as a warning, no expiry date attaches to it and nothing already on the employee's file is replaced by it; when they are in your directory it is saved to their record. Any flags appear on the review panel at the end of the Word and PDF files, marked for the employer's eyes. Remove that page before serving the notice.

For employers

Draft the incapacity hearing notice from your facts.

Draftly drafts the incapacity hearing notice from the facts you enter and your own disciplinary code. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.

What this page will not do

It explains the two incapacity routes Draftly drafts for and what Part F of the Code asks of each. It does not say how long an absence is too long, whether a particular employee can be accommodated, what follows if the employee does not attend, or whether a dismissal for incapacity would be fair.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.