Skip to main content
Draftly for employers
Employer document

Probation outcome letters in South Africa.

When a probationary period runs its course, the employer has a decision to record: the appointment is confirmed, probation is extended, or the appointment will not be confirmed. The letter puts that answer in writing, together with the evaluation it rests on.

What probation is for

A trial of fit, with rules attached.

Part E of the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal of 4 September 2025 deals with probation on its own, apart from misconduct and apart from incapacity. Item 14 lets an employer require a newly hired employee to serve a probationary period before confirming the appointment. Item 15(1) gives the reason: probation is the employer's opportunity to evaluate the person's performance and suitability for employment.

Item 15(2) closes off the obvious abuse. Probation should not be used to keep people out of permanent employment. The Code's own example is an employer that lets probationers go at the end of the period for reasons unconnected with how they performed or whether they suited the job, and hires new people in their place. It calls that inconsistent with the purpose of probation and says it may amount to an unfair dismissal.

Item 16 asks for the length of probation to be fixed in advance and to be reasonable, judged against the nature of the job and how long it takes to tell whether someone suits it. The Code gives no number of weeks or months, and neither does this page. Set the period in advance, and keep it reasonable for the job.

Three possible answers

Confirm, extend, or decline.

The form offers exactly three decisions, and the letter is built around the one you choose.

  • Confirm the appointment. Draftly is told to confirm that the appointment is now permanent from the stated date, with any welcome or next steps you want to include.
  • Extend probation. Draftly is told to set out how long the extension runs and why, the standard that still has to be reached, the support the employer will give, and the new review date. Draftly is told to frame it as a genuine further chance, not an open-ended holding pattern.
  • Do not confirm the appointment. This ends the employment, so it is a dismissal. Draftly is told to give reasons drawn from the evaluation, the effective date, and any notice or pay owed.

A confirmation is the simplest of the three. The other two carry the procedural weight, and most of what follows is about them.

Before an extension or a non-confirmation

Hear the employee first.

Item 18(1) sets the procedural floor. An employer may decide to dismiss a probationer, or to extend the probationary period, only once the employee has had the chance to make representations and the employer has weighed whatever was said. An extension is covered as well, not only a dismissal, so telling someone their probation has been lengthened, without first asking for their side, falls short of the Code.

Item 17 governs the period itself. During probation the employer should give reasonable guidance, appropriate to the nature and size of the employer and to the job, which may include instruction, training or counselling, so that the employee has an opportunity to render a satisfactory service. The letter should be able to point to the guidance that was actually given, with dates.

Item 18(2) has to be read alongside it. It says that whoever decides on the fairness of a dismissal during or at the end of probation, for conduct or for capacity including poor work performance, ought to accept reasons that may be less compelling than for an employee who has completed probation. A lighter standard for the reason is not a lighter standard for the process. Item 18(1) still applies in full.

A non-confirmation is a dismissal under section 186(1)(a) of the Labour Relations Act, and section 188 requires a fair reason and a fair procedure. Section 191(1)(b)(i) sets the time limit for a former probationer who contests the decision. The ordinary rule is a referral to the CCMA or a bargaining council within 30 days of the date of dismissal; if the employer's final decision to dismiss, or to uphold the dismissal, comes later than that, the section runs the period from that decision. Draftly's instructions for a non-confirmation include noting the employee's applicable rights, such as referral to the CCMA.

Not a disciplinary letter

Suitability, not an offence.

Item 5(2) of the Code lists conduct, capacity and operational requirements as separate grounds, and misconduct has its own part, Part D. A probation outcome is an assessment of fit for the role. Draftly is told not to use the “in that” charge convention, warning language or your disciplinary code in it.

If the real problem is a deliberate breach of a workplace rule, Draftly is told to flag it on the review panel and not to settle it through the probation letter. That is a choice about which document fits the facts. It is not a claim that a probationer can never be dismissed for misconduct: item 18(2) expressly contemplates dismissal for conduct during probation. Where conduct is the issue, the notice of hearing page describes the route Draftly drafts for it.

Item 15(2) warns that letting probationers go for reasons unrelated to their performance or suitability, and replacing them with new hires, may be an unfair dismissal. Draftly's rules for a non-confirmation say it must never rest on arbitrary, retaliatory or discriminatory grounds, and they name the Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998. Draftly is told to flag a stated reason that looks arbitrary or touches a protected ground rather than the evaluation. It is also told to leave out the employee's ID number, home address and medical details.

What the letter holds

Six sections, one branch.

Draftly's instructions divide the letter into six parts:

  • Letter details: the employee's name, position and department, the probation start and review dates, and the date of the letter.
  • The purpose and background: the appointment was made on probation to assess suitability, probation is an assessment rather than a disciplinary step, and the standard the employee was made aware of.
  • The evaluation during probation: how the employee measured up against that standard, and the guidance, instruction, training and support provided.
  • The decision, stated plainly and matching the option you selected.
  • The detail for that decision, written as the confirm, extend or decline branch described above, where Draftly is told to confirm, for an extension or a non-confirmation, that the employee had the opportunity to make representations and that they were considered.
  • An acknowledgement that the outcome was discussed with the employee, with room for their comments.

The issuing manager signs with name, role and date. The employee's block is headed as an acknowledgement, and Draftly is told to make clear that signing it confirms receipt of the outcome, not agreement with it.

Draftly's instructions also ask for the letter to show that the employee knew the required standard. Part E does not say that in terms; Draftly asks for it as fair practice, not as a Part E rule. It is one more reason to write the standard into the form precisely.

Drafting it with Draftly

What the form asks you for.

Start with the employee, chosen from your directory or entered by hand with their name, employee number and position. The form then marks four fields as required:

  • Decision: confirm, extend or do not confirm. It starts on confirm, so change it if you mean either of the other two.
  • Required standard for the role: the objective standard the employee was told about and measured against.
  • Evaluation, guidance & support during probation: how the employee performed, factually, and what instruction, training and support they received, with dates.
  • Issuing manager name: the person signing the outcome.

The probation start date, the review or end date, the manager's role and the document language are optional, as is the outcome detail box, whose prompt changes with the decision. For an extension it asks for the length, the reason, the standard still to be met, the support and the new review date. For a non-confirmation it asks for the reasons, the effective date and any notice or pay owed. Enter those figures yourself; Draftly is not given a rule for calculating them.

There is no separate box for the employee's representations. Before an extension or a non-confirmation, record in the outcome detail when the employee was invited to respond, what they said, and that you considered it. Without those facts the letter has nothing to rest the item 18(1) step on, and Draftly is told to flag the gap.

Draftly is told to flag certain gaps, and any flags appear on an internal panel on the last page of the Word and PDF files: a non-confirmation with little evaluation behind it, an extension or non-confirmation with no sign the employee was heard, warning or charge language, a missing effective date or pay detail, or a reason that looks arbitrary. That panel is marked for the employer only, so take it out before the letter is handed over.

You do not need a disciplinary code on your account for this letter, and it is not kept as a warning, so no expiry date attaches to it. If the employee is in your directory, the letter is filed on their record. The performance review page covers the routine record that can feed an evaluation like this one.

For employers

Draft the probation outcome letter from your facts.

Draftly drafts the probation outcome letter from the facts you enter. You get an editable Word file and a PDF to check, print and serve. It is a drafting service, not legal advice, and what you serve is your decision.

Where this comes from

Item numbers on this page refer to the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal published on 4 September 2025 (Government Notice 3470, Government Gazette 53294), which is the Code in force. A guide written before that date may number the same ideas differently.

What this page will not do

It explains what Part E expects at the end of probation and what Draftly asks for. It does not set a probation length, cap an extension, calculate notice or pay owed on a non-confirmation, or say whether a particular decision would survive a CCMA referral.

Draftly is a document drafting company. It produces documents based on the information you provide. It is not a substitute for legal advice.